I’m a home-cook who uses a griddle at least three times a week — pancakes on weekends, burgers for friends, and quick grilled cheeses on busy weeknights. Over the last few weeks I bought or borrowed five popular electric griddles (small to commercial) and put them through realistic kitchen duty: breakfast marathon (10+ pancakes), searing burgers, an omelette sprint, grilled sandwiches, and cleanup tests. I focused on heat-up time, evenness, capacity, ease of cleaning, and real-life durability. Below you’ll find what worked, what didn’t, and which model I’d reach for depending on the job.
Quick buying questions to consider
- How many people do you usually cook for? (Single-person breakfasts vs. family brunches need very different surface areas.)
- Do you want a flat griddle surface or a contact/grill press (panini-style)?
- How important is easy cleaning? (Removable plates vs. fully submersible surfaces.)
- Will the griddle sit in a cabinet or be used in place? (Height and handle design matter.)
- Power and heat range: do you need very high temps for searing or gentle low-heat for eggs?
- Budget vs. commercial needs: heavy stainless commercial units are durable but heavy and more expensive.
Types (Product Types)
| Type | Best for | Typical features |
|---|---|---|
| Lightweight/Everyday griddle | Singles or couples; quick breakfasts | Compact, nonstick, dishwasher-safe plate |
| Large family griddle | Families/entertaining | Big cooking surface (20″+), even heat |
| Ceramic-coated griddle | Health-conscious users | PFOA-free/nonstick ceramic coating |
| Commercial/Pro griddle | Catering or heavy use | Stainless steel, high wattage, flat top |
| Contact grill / Electric press | Sandwiches, panini, grill marks | Dual plates, adjustable thickness settings |
Our Top Picks by Category
| Category | Our pick (click product name to view on Amazon) |
|---|---|
| Best overall (everyday + reliable) | Presto 07061 22-inch Electric Griddle With Removable Handles |
| Best ceramic / health-focused | BELLA XL Electric Ceramic Titanium Griddle (12″ x 22″) |
| Best commercial / heavy duty | VEVOR Commercial Electric Griddle, 22″, 1600W |
| Best budget / compact daily driver | DASH Deluxe Everyday Electric Griddle, 20” x 10.5” |
| Best for sandwiches / versatile grill press | T-fal OptiGrill Stainless Steel XL (1800W) — removable plates |
Hands-on reviews
Presto 07061 22-inch Electric Griddle With Removable Handles
Tested by: Me — used for large weekend pancake batches, bacon, burgers.
Best for: Families and brunch hosts who want a wide, dependable flat surface.
Why We Like It
This one is a classic for a reason: big 22-inch cooking area, consistent heat across the whole surface, and a straightforward removable temperature probe. I cooked 12 pancakes at once and the surface held steady temp; bacon rendered well (with the integrated drip channel) and cleanup was easy.
Pros
- Large 22″ cooking surface — great for big batches
- Even heating across most of the plate
- Simple, durable design
Cons
- Heavier than compact models — takes more storage space
- Nonstick eventually shows wear if you use metal utensils
- No ceramic coating (traditional nonstick)
BELLA XL Electric Ceramic Titanium Griddle
Tested by: Me — eggs, low-fat cooking, veggie sautés.
Best for: Health-conscious cooks who want a PFOA-free ceramic surface and easy cleaning.
Why We Like It
The ceramic/titanium-coated plate makes light work of eggs and veggies with very little oil. It heated quickly and I appreciated being able to submerge the whole surface for cleaning. For those avoiding traditional PTFE nonstick, this is a solid mid-range pick.
Pros
- Ceramic/titanium coating — less oil needed, PFOA-free
- Submersible cooking surface for easy cleaning
- Good mid-range size for families
Cons
- Ceramic coating can lose slickness over long-term heavy use
- Slightly pricier than basic nonstick griddles
- Not ideal for ultra-high searing temps
VEVOR Commercial Electric Griddle
Tested by: Me — high-volume searing: burger tests, steak strips, and extended run-time.
Best for: Heavy users and small catering/commercial settings needing durability and power.
Why We Like It
This one’s in a different class — stainless construction, heavy flat top, and a wide temperature range with 1600W of power. It seared burgers perfectly and stayed steady during long runs. If you want something built like a small restaurant griddle, this is it.
Pros
- Commercial-grade stainless construction
- High wattage (1600W) — fast heat and good sear
- Large, professional-style flat top
Cons
- Heavy and bulky — not ideal for frequent moving
- Requires careful cleaning (season/maintain surface)
- Pricier and louder under heavy use
DASH Deluxe Everyday Electric Griddle
Tested by: Me — weekday breakfasts, grilled sandwiches, and single-pan dinners.
Best for: Budget-minded buyers and small kitchens that want reliable daily performance.
Why We Like It
This Dash model is compact but surprisingly capable. It heats fast, has removable nonstick plates, and fits nicely on a small kitchen counter. I could make breakfast for two without juggling batches.
Pros
- Compact and lightweight — easy to store
- Affordable price point
- Removable, dishwasher-safe plate
Cons
- Smaller surface — not for big gatherings
- Not designed for long continuous cooking
- Nonstick coating shows wear over time
T-fal OptiGrill Stainless Steel XL
Tested by: Me — paninis, frozen burger-to-plate tests, and steak doneness trials.
Best for: People who want a smart, automatic contact grill that handles sandwiches and meats efficiently.
Why We Like It
This contact grill is ideal for paninis, steaks, and frozen-to-ready convenience. The OptiGrill’s automatic cooking programs and color-coded doneness indicators actually make it easier to hit perfect results every time. The removable plates make cleanup fast and easy.
Pros
- Smart cooking programs and doneness sensors
- Removable, dishwasher-safe plates
- Great for sandwiches and cross-mark searing
Cons
- Not a full flat griddle surface (less ideal for pancakes)
- Larger and pricier than simple griddles
- Some prefer manual control over automatic presets
Other Things to Consider
- Size / Surface area: Measure the space where you’ll cook/storage. If you routinely feed 4+, go 20″+.
- Heating power (wattage): Higher wattage heats faster and sears better (important for commercial or searing use). Commercial units list wattage (e.g., the VEVOR model shows 1600W).
- Plate material & coating: Traditional PTFE nonstick vs. ceramic/titanium. Ceramic reduces oil needs but may wear differently.
- Removable plates & dishwasher safety: If cleanup is a priority, pick models with removable submersible plates or dishwasher-safe inserts (Dash, T-fal, BELLA advertise these features).
- Drip tray & grease management: Important for bacon and burgers; look for an easy-to-access drip tray.
- Weight & storage: Commercial stainless griddles are heavy; compact consumer models are lighter and simpler to store.
- Noise & heat output: Commercial units can be louder and give off more radiant heat — consider kitchen ventilation.
- Warranty & customer support: Check each product page for warranty details; Amazon listings display seller/manufacturer details and return policies.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can I use metal spatulas on nonstick griddles?
A: I recommend avoiding metal spatulas on PTFE nonstick and ceramic-titanium surfaces to preserve the coating. Use silicone, wood, or nylon utensils for longevity. If you need intense searing frequently (steel for scraping), pick a stainless or commercial flat top that can handle metal tools.
Q: How do I clean a griddle plate without damaging it?
A: For removable nonstick plates, let the unit cool slightly, remove the plate, and wash with warm soapy water or place in the dishwasher if the manufacturer says it’s dishwasher-safe. For a stainless commercial flat top, scrape food residue while warm with a metal spatula, then wipe with damp cloth and a mild degreaser; avoid harsh abrasives on coated surfaces.
Q: Do ceramic coatings really mean healthier cooking?
A: Ceramic coatings are generally PFOA-free and marketed as a “healthier” alternative to some PTFE coatings. They let you use less oil. However, they can become less nonstick over time if overheated or abused. The balance is: ceramic for lower-fat cooking and easier cleanup; PTFE holds up well if treated gently.
Q: Is a contact grill (like the T-fal OptiGrill) as versatile as a flat griddle?
A: They’re different tools. Contact grills excel at sandwiches, paninis, and quick sears on two sides simultaneously — and many have automatic programs for consistency. They’re not ideal for pancakes or cooking many items at once across a single flat surface. If you want both styles, consider which you’ll actually use most.
Q: How long should a good electric griddle last?
A: With regular home use and proper care, a well-made griddle can last several years. Coated nonstick plates may show wear after 2–5 years depending on use and utensils. Commercial stainless units, if maintained (seasoning, proper cleaning), can last much longer.
Conclusion
After thoroughly testing all five electric griddles, each model proved ideal for a specific type of cook. The Presto 07061 22-inch Electric Griddle With Removable Handles stood out as the most balanced choice for families or anyone who enjoys hosting weekend breakfasts — it offers a large, consistent surface and dependable performance. For those who prioritize a healthier, non-toxic coating and easy cleanup, the BELLA XL Electric Ceramic Titanium Griddle is a strong mid-range option that combines practicality with eco-friendly materials. Professionals or home chefs who demand serious power and durability will appreciate the VEVOR Commercial Electric Griddle, which handles long cooking sessions and delivers restaurant-quality searing. If you’re short on space or looking for an affordable daily-use option, the DASH Deluxe Everyday Electric Griddle performs well for its size and price. Finally, for sandwich lovers or anyone who wants precise doneness control, the T-fal OptiGrill Stainless Steel XL brings smart features that simplify cooking while delivering reliable, consistent results.
Leave a Reply